Ecological Archives

REVIEWER'S FORMS

Please complete the following four items before submitting your review

1. Review Tracking Information
2. Comments for the Authors
3. Rating Form
4. Cover Letter to the Data Editor
5. Reviewer information

Submit your review

I. Review Tracking Information

Manuscript number
Author(s)
Title

II. Comments for the Authors

Do not sign your comments unless you wish to be identified to the author(s)

III. RATING FORM

Low --------> High
				Importance to our readers
				Originality of the dataset
				Potential for data to be used by others
				Potential for stimulating new research
				Appropriateness for Ecological Archives
				Clarity of presentation and completeness of the metadata
				Logical consistency, integrity, and quality of the data

RECOMMENDATION TO THE DATA EDITOR

Accept with minor revision

Accept with moderate revision

Possibly accept after major revision

Reject (publishable, but not in this journal)

More appropriate for these journals or archives:

Reject (not worthy of publication)

IV. Cover Letter to the Data Editor

V. Reviewer Information

Name
Address
City
State
Country
Postal Code
E-mail
Fax
Phone

Submit your review

• Please check that all four sections have been filled in, then press the SUBMIT button, below.
• Thank you very much for helping to maintain the quality of Ecological Archives
• Questions? contact the Data Editor